Dr. Zukeran looks at the popular activity of marital arts from a
biblical worldview perspective. He determines that Christians may
safely participate in martial arts as long as they distance themselves
from the Eastern philosophical ideas associated with most forms of
martial arts.
The Origins and Popularity of the Martial Arts
Gliding across the Pacific, the Asian martial arts have become part
of the mainstream of American culture. Today there are an estimated two
to three million practitioners in the United States, 40 percent of which
are children between the ages of 7 and 14.{1} The martial arts industry generates annual revenue topping the $1 billion mark.
Why this rise in popularity? For one thing, people today are
interested in and more willing to accept Eastern ideas. What was once
considered “foreign” is now embraced as old, and thus “tried and true.”
Advocates extol the physical benefits and self- discipline that result
from its practices. Movies further popularize martial arts with films
such as Enter the Dragon, Rush Hour, and the Oscar winning Crouching Tiger-Hidden Dragon. The rise in crime also has people seeking to learn ways to protect themselves and their loved ones.
There are few written records regarding the origin of martial arts.
These are interwoven with myths or verbal traditions that make it
difficult to accurately trace the record. Archaeological evidence
indicates that the martial arts may have begun as early as 2000 BC in
the Fertile Crescent.{2} From there it traveled eastward to India and China.
The father of the Asian martial arts according to the most popular
tradition is an Indian Buddhist Monk named Bodhidharma who arrived in
China in the late fifth century A.D. Settling in a monastery in the
Songshan Mountains located in the Kingdom of Wei, he developed a series
of mind-body exercises designed to improve the health of the monks and
assist them in meditation. Based on the movements of different real and
mythological animals and incorporating concepts from Taoism and Zen
Buddhism, Bodhidharma taught a style of combat known as Shao-lin gung
fu. Gradually, Shao-lin gung fu migrated from the temples to the Chinese
populace. It was adapted and refined as it spread across the country
and eventually, to the world.
Martial arts have been very popular among Christians. Scot Conway,
founder of the Christian Martial Arts Foundation, estimates between 50
and 70 percent of American martial artists — and roughly 20 percent of
all instructors — consider themselves Christians.{3}
But other Christians argue that the philosophy of Asian martial arts is
wholly incompatible with biblical teaching. They point to the origin of
Eastern mysticism as reason for Christians to avoid any level of
participation. Still others say Jesus’ exhortation to “turn the other
cheek” shows that using force is wrong.
How should a discerning Christian respond? Can we participate in the
martial arts and be consistent with our biblical convictions?
Differences in the Martial Arts
Should Christians participate in the martial arts? In order to make
an informed decision, it is helpful to recognize that there are two
basic categories for martial arts. It is important to note that the
division is not rigid; in some cases, values from one type may be
blended or subtly integrated into the other. But for simplicity and
clarity, we will use the two main groups.
One type, called “internal” or “soft” martial art, focuses on inner
spiritual development, balance, form, and mental awareness. This soft
art emphasizes two principles — that the mind dictates action and that
the opponent’s own force is used to defeat him or her.{4}
Students are taught Taoist and Buddhist philosophical principles such
as the “chi” force and the “yin and yang” concept. Through breath
control, soft art practitioners seek to “collect, cultivate, and store”
this chi force which is located in the body. Some believe they can use
the chi force to strike down opponents from a distance. Examples of
internal or soft martial arts include the Chinese Tai-chi Chuan and the
Japanese Aikido.
The second category of martial arts is called the “external” or
“hard” art. This type teaches that physical reactions precede mental
reaction. It also promotes the idea that an opponent’s force should be
met with an equal but opposite force. While the hard martial art system
also uses breath control like the soft arts, the emphasis is on
developing strength and quickness through the use of straight and linear
body motions.{5}
The hard arts include certain forms of Chinese kung fu, and Shao Lin
boxing. The Japanese arts were adapted from Chinese kung fu. The hard
arts include Ju-jitsu, Judo, Karate, Ninjitsu, and Kendo. The Korean
martial arts include Tae Kwon Do and Tang Soo Do.
While there are religious concepts in the martial arts, few schools
would qualify as religious movements, and few seek to meet the religious
needs of the student. However, a little exposure to Eastern mysticism
may lead to greater involvement in the future. So as a general rule,
Christians should avoid the internal or soft martial arts because of the
concentration on the teachings of Eastern religions and philosophies.
Several schools even utilize the occult techniques of meditation and
altering consciousness. External or hard martial arts, on the other
hand, concentrate primarily on physical training. These physical lessons
usually do not conflict with our biblical convictions.
Before joining a dojo or martial arts gym, one needs to know the
worldview of the instructor. Even some hard martial arts teachers
incorporate Eastern ideas and occult practices into their styles. Look
for instructors who teach the physical movements but exclude the Eastern
ideas.
Eastern Concepts in the Martial Arts
Since martial arts are traditionally based on the Eastern
philosophies of Taoism and Zen Buddhism, several key concepts can be
prominent in the classes. Let’s look at three of them.
The concept of “chi” or “ki” is central in some martial arts. Chi is
believed to be the impersonal life energy that flows throughout the
universe and pulses through the human body. By harnessing the chi in
individuals, martial artists believe they can perform at higher levels
of ability or can release chi power resulting in devastating effects.
Chi is controlled through specialized breathing techniques, gymnastics,
and meditation.
Another common martial arts teaching is the Taoist (pronounced
“dow-ist”) concept of yin and yang, that nature consists of conflicting
elements which function in perfect balance to one another. As mankind
should live in harmony with the Tao, so the martial artist must strike
hard with firmness at times, but at other times accept the energy of the
opponent, then reroute the energy, causing the opponent to defeat
himself. This redirection allows a relatively gentle resolution, and
brings one into harmony with the opponent and the flow of nature.
A Christian must also avoid the practice of Eastern meditation. The
goal of this type of meditation is to empty one’s mind, alter one’s
consciousness, or unite with the impersonal divine. Scott Shaw writes,
“Meditation is a sacred process. It is the method used by the spiritual
warrior to calm the mind and to connect the body and mind with the
infinite.”{6} This
greater awareness supposedly enables the martial artist to increase his
or her performance. In many schools, the combined use of Eastern
meditation and the chi are essential to mastering the art. (Not all
martial arts use meditation for this purpose. Some use it to focus on
the lesson or task at hand such as picturing the action in your mind
before physically carrying it out.)
But the mysticism of Taoism and Buddhism is not compatible with
Christianity; neither is Eastern meditation the same as biblical
meditation. The Bible does not teach altering our consciousness or
emptying our minds. Instead, the goal of Scriptural meditation is to fill
our minds with God’s Word. (Psalm 1:2) Another danger of Eastern
meditation is that it can open our minds to the occult, a practice the
Bible prohibits. The Bible does not teach the Eastern idea of chi, that
there is an impersonal life energy of the universe within us. Rather,
the Bible says that each individual has an eternal soul that will either
go to heaven or to hell based on whether or not they have a
relationship with Christ.
Self Defense or Turn the Other Cheek?
Besides concerns about the role of Eastern religion in the martial
arts, some people think martial arts encourages violence. Martial arts
teach fighting, and so are contrary to the Bible’s instructions about
pacifism. Is there ever a time when Christians can use force?
Christian pacifists believe it is always wrong to injure another
person. Many interpret Jesus’ teaching in Matthew 5:38-48, where he
states, “Do not resist an evil person. If someone strikes you on the
right cheek, turn to him the other also . . .”, to mean never use
violence. This is exemplified in the life of Christ who suffered
silently and did not retaliate while enduring torture even unto death.
Despite these arguments, the proper interpretation of the Matthew 5
passage does not teach pacifism. In Jewish culture, to be struck or
slapped on the cheek was an insult (2 Corinthians 11:20). Jesus was
teaching that when a disciple is insulted for being a follower of
Christ, the disciple should not retaliate with force. However, being
insulted is a very different situation from being attacked by a mugger
or your wife being attacked by a rapist.
In the Gospels, Christ did not resist violent attacks because of His
unique mission to be the sacrifice for our sins. However, in the Old
Testament, the preincarnate Christ judged wicked nations with the sword.
(Judges 6:11-16). Not only did He smite His enemies, He aided Israel in
being an instrument of judgment as well. Revelation predicts the
glorified Christ coming to judge the nations with a sword. Also in the
New Testament, Jesus and His disciples did not teach military leaders to
withdraw from the military (e.g., Matthew 8:8-13, Luke 3:14). In Romans
13, Paul writes that the government has the right to “bear the sword.”
In other words, a righteous government can use capital punishment when
an offender is worthy of death.
Therefore, complete pacifism is not the spirit of Christian teaching.
In fact, the most loving thing to do when a friend or family member is
attacked by a harmful foe is to risk one’s life and use force to
restrain the enemy. If a man is attacking a child, or a woman is being
raped, it would be morally wrong not to sacrifice your life and restrain
the assailant even with deadly force if necessary.
The Bible allows a Christian to use self-defense and force when
confronted with a criminal act. Force may not be used for revenge or out
of unjust anger. Christians who engage in the martial arts should have a
clear understanding of this. The use of martial arts must be for
self-defense and protecting loved ones from acts of evil. One should
never use their fighting system to instigate combat or seek revenge.
Should Christians Participate in the Martial Arts?
To summarize what I have covered so far, I believe that the physical
aspect of martial arts can be separated from the Eastern religious and
philosophical teachings. Also, I believe the Bible teaches us that there
is a time when we are called to use force, even deadly force to halt
acts of evil.
Here are some practical guidelines if one is deciding to participate
in the martial arts or if one is selecting a school. First, a person
should check his or her motives. One should not engage in martial arts
if one’s motives include becoming a tough guy, showing off, or gaining
revenge. Parents should make it clear to their children that the martial
arts are never to be used for affectation or for instigating conflicts.
Unworthy motives are detrimental to one’s walk with the Lord and
witness to others. Positive reasons include physical conditioning,
discipline, and self-defense. Develop parameters for limiting the use of
force. One of the fruits of the Spirit is self-control. Force is used
in defensive purposes only.
Generally speaking, Christians should avoid the soft or internal form
of martial arts because they tend to emphasize Eastern philosophical
and religious ideas. External or hard martial arts emphasize the
physical training. However, it would be wise to be on guard because many
instructors of external martial arts may incorporate Eastern mysticism
in to their system. Also, one should be careful to avoid the possibility
of being enticed to learn about Eastern spirituality as they advance.
Find out the worldview of the instructor. The role of religion in the
martial arts depends mostly on the instructor, so choosing a proper
instructor is the most important factor. Some instructors claim to teach
the physical aspect only. However, as students advance, instructors
begin to incorporate Eastern religious ideas to help students attain a
higher level of performance. Observe advanced classes to see if they
incorporate Eastern practices. There is also helpful information through
Christian organizations such as Karate for Christ and the Christian
Martial Arts Foundation.
The Christian life involves caring for the nurture and growth of our
mind, spirit, and our body which is the temple of the Holy Spirit. I
have benefited greatly from my time in the martial arts. It has provided
me great exercise, discipline, and opportunities to witness for Christ.
There were times in my life when I had to use force to restrain hostile
persons or protect loved ones. I believe that the martial arts can be
beneficial to Christians who are informed and mature.
Notes
1. Glenn Rifkin, “The Black Belts of the Screen Are Filling the Dojos,” The New York Times, 16 February 1992, 10.
2. Howard Reid and Michael Croucher, The Way of the Warrior, (Woodstock, NY.: Overlook Press, 1983), 16-17.
3. Erwin Castro, B.J. Oropeza, and Ron Rhodes, “Enter the Dragon?
Wrestling with the Martial Arts Phenomenon Part I,” Christian Research
Institute, http://www.equip.org/free/dm066.htm, 2.
4. Reid and Croucher, The Way of the Warrior, 229.
5. Ibid., 61 & 227.
6. Scott Shaw, The Warrior is Silent (Rochester, VT.: Inner Traditions International, 1998), 53.
Bibliography
1. Ankerberg, John, and Weldon, John. Encyclopedia of New Age Beliefs. Eugene, Ore.: Harvest House Publishers, 1996.
2. Musashi, Miyamoto. A Book of Five Rings, trans. Victor Harris. Woodstock, NY.: Overlook Press.
3. Partridge, Christopher. Dictionary of Contemporary Religion in the Western World. Downer’s Grove, Ill.: InterVarsity Press, 2002.
4. Reid, Howard and Croucher, Michael, The Way of the Warrior, Woodstock, NY.: Overlook Press, 1983.
5. Shaw, Scott. The Warrior is Silent. Rochester, VT.: Inner Traditions International, 1998.
6. Smith, Jonathan. The Harper Collins Dictionary of Religion. San Francisco: Harper Collins Publishers, 1995.
7. Suzuki, D.T. Zen and Japanese Culture. New York: MJF Books, 1959.
8. Tzu, Sun. The Art of War, trans. Gary Gagliardi. Shoreline, WA.: Clearbridge Publishing 2001.
Web Articles
1. “Should a Christian Practice the Martial Arts?” Christian Research Institute.
http://www.equip.org/free/DM065.htm
2. Castro, Erwin, Oropeza, B.J., and Rhodes, Ron. “Enter the Dragon? Wrestling with the Martial Arts Phenomenon, Part I” Christian Research Institute.
http://www.equip.org/free/DM066.htm
3. _____. “Enter the Dragon? Wrestling with the Martial Arts Phenomenon Part II” Christian Research Institute. http://www.equip.org/free/DM067.htm
©2003 Probe Ministries.
Post Views:
5,849
Related Posts
Christian Worldview Links
Here are some other sites that we suggest are worth checking
out.Worldview Academy Worldview Academy is a non-denominational ministry
committed to training students and parents to think and live…
-
"Why Isn't Jesus Called Joshua?"I
was born of Jewish parents, but never confirmed in the Jewish faith. I
was baptized at a Billy Graham rally in 1952. I have questioned why
writings about Jesus…
Mind Games 2016 ScheduleMind
Games 2016 Schedule SUNDAY MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
SATURDAY 7:30 Devotions Devotions Devotions Devotions Devotions 8:00
Breakfast Breakfast Breakfast Breakfast Breakfast Breakfast Clean…
Photoshopping LifeWhen
Ray and I visited the Galapagos Islands, one of my favorite pictures
was the two of us with a gigantic tortoise. Unfortunately, my big ol'
red purse was on…
Dr. Patrick Zukeran,
former Probe staffer, is the founder and Executive Director of Evidence
and Answers, a research and teaching ministry specializing in Christian
apologetics, the defense of the Christian faith. He is the host of the
radio show Evidence and Answers (www.evidenceandanswers.org). Pat is the author of several books including The Apologetics of Jesus co-authored with Norman Geisler; God, Eternity, and Spirituality (ed.); and Unless I See . . . Is There Enough Evidence to Believe?
Pat is a popular conference speaker and he also serves as an adjunct
faculty for several colleges and institutes worldwide. He earned a B.A.
from Point Loma Nazarene University, a Master of Theology (Th.M.) from
Dallas Theological Seminary, and a Doctorate of Ministry (D.Min.) in
Apologetics from Southern Evangelical Seminary. Pat lives in Honolulu,
Hawaii and can be reached at pat@evidenceandanswers.org.
About Probe Ministries
Probe Ministries is a non-profit ministry whose mission is to assist
the church in renewing the minds of believers with a Christian worldview
and to equip the church to engage the world for Christ. Probe fulfills
this mission through our Mind Games conferences for youth and adults,
our 3-minute daily radio program, and our extensive Web site at www.probe.org.
Further information about Probe's materials and ministry may be obtained by contacting us at:
Probe Ministries
2001 W. Plano Parkway, Suite 2000
Plano TX 75075
(972) 941-4565
info@probe.org
www.probe.org
Copyright/Reproduction Limitations
This document is the sole property of Probe Ministries. It may not be
altered or edited in any way. Permission is granted to use in digital
or printed form so long as it is circulated without charge, and in its
entirety. This document may not be repackaged in any form for sale or
resale. All reproductions of this document must contain the copyright
notice (i.e., Copyright 2021 Probe Ministries) and this
Copyright/Limitations notice.
Another link of interest
What is a Christian Warrior?